【】
Welcome toFix It, our series examining projects we love — save for one tiny change we wish we could make.
Mike Schur's afterlife comedy,The Good Place, is an example of a show that didn't always have a perfect execution, but it always had perfect vibes. Even at its lowest points, it was still a beautiful, optimistic work that made viewers really think about what it means to be human and, in its oft-quoted Scanlon catchphrase, "What we owe to each other."
One of the reasons The Good Place's rare combination of half-hour network comedy and intense moral philosophy discourse actually worked is because of the amount of effort its creators took to get the philosophy part right. People wrote articles about what moral philosophers thought of The Good Place("Whenever Chidi gives those quick philosophy lessons and explains what people were saying, it’s always completely right and pretty accessible"); the many schools of ethical thoughtthe show drew from to find its moral center ("The Good Placehas laid out a moral vision that’s surprisingly sophisticated and deeply informed by academic philosophy"); and the impact of the show's philosophy on human psychology("For a light and amusing sitcom, The Good Placedoes a pretty good job with philosophy, and a pretty good job with human psychology, too"). The level of care taken with the study of ethics is evidence that the writers took this stuff seriously; as a result, the audience took their messages to heart.
Unfortunately, that same level of care was not applied to researching other things, or really just one thing as far as I can tell. There's a grossly incorrect line in The Good PlaceSeason 3 that has nothing to do with moral philosophy but is nonetheless completely baffling to...pretty much only me, if I'm being honest. I don't think I've ever met anyone else who was bothered by it, but it bothers me so much that if I could change one thing aboutThe Good Place, it would be this ridiculous line of dialogue.
Prime Day deals you can shop right now
Products available for purchase here through affiliate links are selected by our merchandising team. If you buy something through links on our site, Mashable may earn an affiliate commission.iRobot Roomba Combo j7+ Self-Emptying Robot Vacuum and Mop—$698.99(List Price $1099.99)
Samsung Galaxy Tab A9+ 10.9" 64GB Wi-Fi Tablet—$142.49(List Price $219.99)
Apple AirPods Pro 2nd Gen With MagSafe USB-C Charging Case—$168.99(List Price $249.00)
Fitbit Charge 6 Fitness Tracker With 6-Months Membership—$99.95(List Price $159.95)
Apple Watch Series 9 (GPS, 41mm, Midnight, S/M, Sports Band)—$279.99(List Price $399.00)
In Season 3, Episode 8, "Don't Let the Good Life Pass You By," the main characters have a fight scene with the Bad Place employees in a Canadian bar. Janet handles most of the combat and unleashes a can of not-a-robot whoop-ass on the demons, but Tahani gets a good crack in when she grabs a pool cue and faces off with a demon of her own. "Twelve years of fencing," she explains, "en garde!" Tahani then grips the cue with both hands. brings it down on the demon's head, and says, "Obviously I'd never do that in competition; that would be a three-tenths deduction."
Fencing is one of those sports that sounds really cool because it's sword fighting, but is actually kind of dweeby because it's mostly footwork and figuring out which fencer has the right of way on the strip. Naturally, I fenced competitively for years. I was a foil fencer, which meant that my job was to stick people with the pointy end, but looking at Tahani's terrible form, it appears she fenced saber, the version of the sport where you whack people with the side of your blade.
Tahani's incorrect positioning (legs too straight, not low enough to the ground), her swap from gripping the pool cue/blade with one hand to two (doesn't happen), and her lack of attention to spacing in reference to her opponent (she's waytoo close) could be explained by her being out of practice and under duress. Her line about the three-tenths deduction, however, is inexplicable. There are no deductions in fencing. There are only touches, fencing's version of points, and they're awarded in positive integers, not in tenths. The only way to earn something like a deduction is if the fencer earns a red card by being a jerk, and even that awards a touch to their opponent — it doesn't remove a touch from their own score.
I know the three-tenths thing is just a joke, but it's not a particularly good one.
I know the three-tenths thing is just a joke, but it's not a particularly good one. Tahani's whole thing is being an over-the-top rich lady who's obsessed with the rules of polite society, and giving her a flighty line about fencing point deductions doesn't add to her character or make the scene funnier. It's just bizarrely and glaringly wrong. The Good Placewas smart enough to explain Aristotelian virtue ethics but they couldn't check to see how an Olympic sport worked? That's some weak sauce.
The three-tenths fencing line is not important at all, and yet, I cannot let it go. Every time I think about The Good PlaceSeason 3, which was not its best season anyway, I think about the writers sacrificing an easily googleable fact for an unnecessary joke. It doesn't stop The Good Placefrom being an incredible show that accomplished something totally unique on TV, but it loses three-tenths of a point from me for disrespecting the sport, nay, theartof fencing.
All seasons of The Good Placeare streaming on Netflix.
Related Video: What to binge on the best 30-day streaming service free trials
相关文章
J.K. Rowling makes 'Harry Potter' joke about Olympics event
LONDON -- For anyone who isn't familiar with the Olympics omnium events in the velodrome, the points2024-09-20- 女足亞洲杯多隊出現確診病例 亞足聯:夠13人就繼續踢_比賽_參賽_越南www.ty42.com 日期:2022-01-20 16:01:00| 評論(已有326819條評論)2024-09-20
- 巧合?本賽季西甲武磊9場枯坐板凳 球隊勝率僅22%_西班牙人_聯賽_戰績www.ty42.com 日期:2022-01-22 07:31:00| 評論(已有327117條評論)2024-09-20
- 越南主帥關注球員文身 囑咐年輕隊員要集中精力備戰_樸恒緒_訓練_清平www.ty42.com 日期:2022-01-20 09:01:00| 評論(已有326659條評論)2024-09-20
- Amazon's Echo made controlling music with your voice easy-peasy, but its sound quality could be a lo2024-09-20
- 粵媒:水慶霞首秀布陣有亮點 廣州隊小將表現活躍_中國女足_王霜_張馨www.ty42.com 日期:2022-01-21 10:31:00| 評論(已有326967條評論)2024-09-20
最新评论